Articles from and news about the premier and longest-running academic journal devoted to all aspects of cartooning and comics -- the International Journal of Comic Art (ISSN 1531-6793) published and edited by John Lent.

Friday, August 14, 2026

Graphic novel review - MrBallen Presents: Strange, Dark, & Mysterious: The Graphic Stories

 reviewed by Lizzy Walker, Wichita State University

John B. Allen, Robert Venditti, and Andrea Mutti, with cover art by Rob Prior. MrBallen Presents: Strange, Dark, & Mysterious: The Graphic Stories. Emeryville, California: Ten Speed Graphic, 2024. 208 pages, $24.99 978-1984863423. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/742533/mrballen-presents-strange-dark-and-mysterious-by-stories-by-mrballen-illustrations-by-andrea-mutti/

 

            Former Navy SEAL and renowned storyteller John B. Allen, known as MrBallen online, has entertained audiences with his unique and conversational narration style, with a focus on the weird and unexplained on his YouTube channel. He also developed two podcasts: MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious, and MrBallen's Medical Mysteries. In MrBallen Presents: Strange, Dark & Mysterious: The Graphic Stories, Allen, adapter Venditti, and artist Mutti turn nine of Allen's tales from his popular YouTube channel into a collection of tales of the macabre.

            While all of the stories leave their mark, there are a few that stand out. Allen relates what tragedies befell a number of people who ventured into "The Valley of Headless Men," located in the Nahanni Valley in the Northwest Territories. The allegedly haunted valley is plagued by strange and horrifying events. Those who venture in to search for and reclaim the dead often find grisly scenes, and headless bodies. Nobody knows what is in the valley, but some whisper about white demons, waheela, or something else. Allen shares various stories of tragic events, such as accounts of gold prospectors who never make it out of the valley, a group of hunters in 1926 where one of the party, Annie Laferte, goes missing, and a strange creature is scene stalking the forest later; and other tragedies that happened along the years.  

            "Thorns" tells of Elsa, who became a camp counselor in 2012, and had fond memories of the camp as she attended it herself as a child. The first night at the camp in her new role, she is tormented by a horrific nightmare, expertly illustrated in a simple red, black, and white color pallet by Mutti, where strange men are forcing a crown of thorns over her head in front of an angry crowd. As she screams in pain, vibrant blood drips rivulets down her face. When she wakes up, she finds her head aching and her hands are covered in blood.

            "What I Saw in My Room Still Haunts Me" is a personal story of Allen as a teenager when he sees something enter the room where he and his friends are staying in New Hampshire. It happens three nights in a row, culminating in a message for his friend's mother, a recent widow.

In "The Beast of Gévaudan," Jacques is endlessly bullied by other children for being a sensitive soul. He dreams of following in his uncle's footsteps and joining the clergy, but his village earns a living by farming and tending livestock. Children had been found killed in the pastures and fields, mangled viciously by what villagers initially thought was a wild animal. However, with the pattern of killings, they eventually come up with supernatural theories for the murders. From that point, the children responsible for tending the sheep ventured out in groups, one such being Jacques, his brother Jean, the ringleader of the former's bullying, and a few others. One of the boys suggests that Jacques, an expert storyteller, relay something to pass the time, which he does. Unfortunately, the focus is pulled away from the flock as the story starts to get good. Jean is taken by the beast. Now, Jacques must decide: face his fears or run away like the other children.

"Make It Rain," set in 1983, follows Don Decker who is on furlough from a jail sentence to attend his late grandfather's funeral, not out of affection, but as a way to get out of his cell for a short time. He hated the man, and his ire raises as he listens to the well wishes and grief pouring from the other funeral goers. After he leaves the services when he sees the corpse move and look in his direction, Don becomes haunted, perhaps possessed, by the dead man.  

            Other stories included in this collection are "La Mussara," in which some friends out on a hike visit an abandoned Spanish town with a strange past; "Bells Canyon," where a businessman spends what he hopes to be a relaxing stay in the woods away from the bustling city turns into a few nights of terror; a group of Green Berets face a sinister, legendary creature in "The Kandahar Giant," and a Russian hunter becomes the hunted in "Cat and Mouse."               

As mentioned, Allen has a conversational and personal way of telling a story, something which New York Times bestselling graphic novelist Venditti succeeds in conveying this adaptation. Mutti's inclusion of Allen's likeness at points in the stories emphasizes the storyteller's intrusion, albeit welcome, in the narrative.

Mutti's distinct and realistic artwork is fitting for this collection.    

The book includes a location map where the stories take place, a section of recommendations for further reading for each story, and short biographies of Allen and Mutti, as well as information on Ballen Studios.

 


No comments: