International Journal of Comic Art blog

Articles from and news about the premier and longest-running academic journal devoted to all aspects of cartooning and comics -- the International Journal of Comic Art (ISSN 1531-6793) published and edited by John Lent.

Thursday, February 26, 2026

Comics and the Global South open-access book

Comics and the Global South

Methodologies from and within Majority Worlds

Andrea Aramburú (Editor), Dibyadyuti Roy (Editor), Joe Sutliff Sanders (Editor)

Leuven University Press, 2026

online at 



Original comics scholarship offering methodologies developed from the histories, artistic traditions, and socio-political contexts of comics and visual cultures from the Global South.

Comics, graphic novels and webtoons are exploding in popularity across the Global South and Majority World(s). Because most of the critical and methodological tools in English-language comics scholarship come from the Global North, such approaches are often imperfectly designed to illuminate Global South/Global Majority specificities, innovations, and achievements. Comics and the Global South brings together original comics scholarship that offers methodologies crafted within the histories, artistic traditions, and social and political realities of the comics and visual cultures in and from the Global South. The contributions make a major breakthrough in our ability to understand comics of the Global South on their own terms.


Table of Contents (pp. 5-6) OPEN ACCESS

  • Introduction (pp. 7-22)
    Andrea Aramburú, Dibyadyuti Roy and Joe Sutliff Sanders
    OPEN ACCESS

    The year 2024, shortly before this anthology on comics and the Global South went into production, marked an unprecedented moment in global electoral history, with a record-breaking number of voters participating in general elections across 64 nations, surpassing any previous democratic exercise in human history (Ewe 2023). Amongst the dominance of data- and algorithm-driven (mis)information, toxic political debates, and polarising social media discourse during these global exercises of adult franchise, which threatened to eclipse individual and collective agency, there was a decisive re-emergence of visual storytelling, particularly comics, as vital cultural territories of meaning-making. With 70 percent of the top...


  • CHAPTER ONE Hong Kong Comics: A Liminal Space Bridging the Global South and the Global North (pp. 23-44)
    Kin-Wai Chu
    OPEN ACCESS

    Comics, with their rich transcultural history as both an art form, a medium, and a cultural product, reflect and shape the evolving dynamics of culture, politics, and society. Hence, they offer a unique lens to explore complex cross-border interactions. This chapter examines the Global North and South dichotomy through the lens of Hong Kong comics.

    Although the term Global South lacks a single definition, the United Nations uses it to describe less economically developed countries predominantly located in the southern hemisphere, contrasting with the developed nations mainly in the Global North (UNCTD 2018). This term, which replaced "Third World" after...


  • CHAPTER TWO Digital Dreams and Its Discontents: Piracy and Comics in South America (pp. 45-64)
    Amadeo Gandolfo
    OPEN ACCESS

    Piracy is the elephant in the room when discussing comics distribution for large portions of readers living in the Global South. This article seeks to grapple with this topic first by contributing to a discussion on intellectual resource imbalances between North and South. The academic system is inherently unequal between North and South. The most prestigious academic publishing houses are thought to belong to the United States and Europe, premier amongst them university presses. The subscription system for journals is priced in high sums of dollars and euros, particularly difficult to sustain for universities of the South, and impossible for...


  • CHAPTER THREE Working with the Frames: Retellings and Reconstructions in Indian Graphic Narratives (pp. 65-82)
    Amrutha Mohan
    OPEN ACCESS

    A predisposition to visual storytelling has always been part of Asia's cultural and historical legacy. Caricatures have been a continuing presence in the Asian art traditions, and hence the ingredients of comic art were long present in Asia (Lent 2015, 11–12). By citing examples from Japan and India about the art that existed in the continent, Lent further adds that "ancient murals, sculptures, painted scrolls; woodcuts and other drawings and picture books did indeed contain one or more of the elements of cartooning, such as caricature, satire/parody, humour/playfulness, and narrative/sequence" (2015, 10). From engravings found in prehistoric caves to...


  • CHAPTER FOUR Out of the Frame: The Third Space in Indian Graphic Narratives (pp. 83-104)
    Debanjana Nayek
    OPEN ACCESS

    In 1975, The Adventures of Tintin arrived in India as a translated series in a regional magazine of Calcutta, Anandamela. The Bengali translation of Tintin became a cultural phenomenon for generations of comics enthusiasts in the city. The Bengali Tintin is not merely a literal translation of Hergé's work; it has shaped the narrative within the socio-cultural context of Calcutta. In a discussion on regional comics of Bengal, it is observed that the "sophisticated Bengalis regarded gneri-gugli as lowly food that poor people scrounged from riverbanks, giving Haddock's outburst a piquantly Bengali punch while preserving the crustacean flavour of the...


  • CHAPTER FIVE Deconstructing the "Gutter": A Decolonial Study of the Journey from Patachitra to Comics in Famine Tales (pp. 105-124)
    Rounak Gupta and Partha Bhattacharjee
    OPEN ACCESS

    In the remediated graphic representation of Kabir's "I cannot be a devotee when I am hungry," artist Sekhar Mukherjee develops a fold-out fixed inset of the collection (2023, 152–53; Fig. 5.1). This fold-out resembles a three-part horizontal scroll with every part separated by a white border. Instead of making the three parts separate entities to form a sequence, it illustrates a single moment where the poem about dearth and famine finds itself inside the speech balloons. The speech balloon strangely resembles an empty human stomach hinting towards numerous stories of famished conditions we encounter on every page of the...


  • CHAPTER SIX Malungas: A Global South Feminist Epistemology in Comics (pp. 125-142)
    Letícia Simões
    OPEN ACCESS

    In early 2000s, with the rise of left-wing governments, public policies promoting historical reparations led to a significant increase in access to universities and cultural funding for Black and marginalised communities all over Latin America. In Brazil, this political shift diversified the aesthetic landscape of Brazilian culture, foregrounding Afro-Brazilian, Indigenous, and peripheral narratives and visual forms that had long been suppressed. However, with the far-right resurgence in late 2010s, this pluralistic aesthetic was pushed back: symbolic codes favouring whiteness, heteronormativity, and conservative ideals regained dominance in public discourse and cultural production. In Brazilian capitals, specifically in 2013, a popular movement...


  • CHAPTER SEVEN Global South Comics and the Crisis of Postcolonial Masculinity: Case Studies from Bangladesh and India (pp. 143-172)
    Dibyadyuti Roy and Swarnima Banerjee
    OPEN ACCESS

    In the inaugural volume of Ms. Shabash—published on International Women's Day in 2015 by Bangladesh's Mighty Punch Studios—the titular character and superhero alter-ego of journalist Shabnam Sharif successfully thwarts a daring robbery attempt. However, instead of public acclaim, she is unexpectedly besieged with marriage proposals from invasive male fans and seemingly well-intentioned elderly women. As the suspended-in-air Ms. Shabash politely but assertively brushes away these approaches by noting, "I have to get back to my day job," readers are immediately made aware of the normative attitudes and gendered anxieties that attempt to confine postcolonial female agency within restrictive...


  • CHAPTER EIGHT The Upper and Lower Jaws (pp. 173-198)
    Zak Waipara
    OPEN ACCESS

    Rigidly imposed definitions and assumptions have at times framed discussions of what constitutes comics and comics-making in Aotearoa New Zealand and, in so doing, excluded marginalised communities from the conversation. Accepting such views verbatim closes off the potential to expand the art form and recognise the interesting work being done by creators who exist outside narrow definitions.

    Examining the background to comics in New Zealand shows why a lack of bicultural competency might lead to both the co-option of Māori themes, stories, and motifs by non-Māori comic makers and the exclusion of meaningful discourse that links comics and traditional Māori...


  • CHAPTER NINE Towards Indomanga: ONJ Mangaesque Narratives from India (pp. 199-228)
    Ananya Saha
    OPEN ACCESS

    Manga and anime have acquired extensive global visibility in the 21st century. Popular anime titles are streaming on OTT platforms (Netflix, Crunchyroll), and the fandom is participating in enthusiastic digital exchanges. Several manga otakus¹ are not just mere consumers, but active partakers of the creative process. Alvin Toffler coined the portmanteau term "prosumer" in his book The Third Wave (1980), referring to the production by a consumer. The notion has reverberated within the realm of manga fandom. Creatively endowed fans often yield original texts that can be identified as ONJ (Original Non-Japanese) manga. The opus of ONJ includes OEL (Original...


  • CHAPTER TEN Drawing Slavery "With and Against the Archive" in Jesús Cossio's Joaquín Jayme (pp. 229-254)
    Andrea Aramburú
    OPEN ACCESS

    In 2014, Ricardo Caro Cárdenas found in the Presbítero Maestro cemetery in Lima, Perú, the grave of Joaquín Jayme, a freed slave. The grave bore the following inscription: "Born in Africa. Died on September 12, 1870. At 94 years of age" (Arrelucea Barrantes et al. 2016, 42).¹ It was rare for Afro-Peruvian individuals who had been enslaved, even those who had acquired their freedom prior to the abolition of slavery, to be buried with a name and surname in a cemetery. More commonly, the anonymous bodies were deposited in a shared grave. Jayme was possibly amongst the group of Africans...


  • CHAPTER ELEVEN Birthing Beyond Borders: The Role of Comics in Dadaab Refugee Camps (pp. 255-270)
    Caroline Bagelman, Jen Bagelman and Josephine Gitome
    OPEN ACCESS

    Dadaab is host to one of the world's largest and longest-standing refugee camp complexes.¹ Located in north-east Kenya in the Garissa County, the camps were constructed in 1991 as a "temporary" shelter for the thousands of Somali refugees fleeing the civil war, which bears the indelible mark of the region's former colonial powers who imposed boundaries that became the fault lines for conflict. While humanitarian funding for Dadaab has declined, alongside threats of imminent demolition, the camp and its residents—who cannot be repatriated due to ongoing conflict—remain there indefinitely. In this space, women face enduring challenges in maternal...



  • Tuesday, February 24, 2026

    IGJOCA fanzine for John A. Lent online now

    Thanks to everyone who contributed. John got it today and was laughing when he called me about it. 


    Here's our AI-generated (literally but heavily edited) Table of Contents.

    Page. Title - Author/Artist

    1. Cover - Matt Wuerker
    2. A Visual Representation of the Esteemed Dr. John A. Lent... - Lizzy Walker
    3. The financial, economic, scientific, and technological implications of Scrooge McDuck's Twenty-Four Carat Moon - Mike Rhode
    4. Re-thinking comics for reading in microgravity - Maaheen Ahmed
    4. 'I Still Have Some Vegetables and Some Styrofoam Left!': Food Processing as Cosmic Jouissance in Secret Wars II - José Alaniz
    5. John Lent is really Hari Seldon! - ct lim (Magnifico Giganticus)
    6. The Consequences of AI for Comic Strips - David Beard
    7, Feminism and Fishnets: The Accidental Legacy of Black Canary - Matt Morrison
    7. Spirals at the Edge of the Milky Way: New Intergalactic Perspectives on Junji Ito's Uzumaki - Lizzy Walker
    8. Superpowers or Natural Abilities?: A Comparison of Superhero Abilities on Earth and Planet X - Lizzy Walker
    8. "What this country needs is a strong bibliographer!" - Mike Rhode, modifying Jefferson Machamer*
    9. My Academic Hero: Summary of the Colloquium of Comics Scholars... - Troy Michael Bordun
    10. Semiotic Non-Verbal Conventions During States of Unplanned Disassembly
    In Early Katzenjammer Kids "advertisement" - Miron Murcury
    10. Comics Research Bibliography: Our 479th Edition "advertisement" - Mike Rhode, modifying Stout*
    11 "Happily Ever After": Veterans and Demobilization in Post-Disney War XC War Comics Stephen Connor
    12. Anecdotally Overheard - Mark C. Rogers
    12. Must Devour More Comics! - Marc C. Rogers with Mike Rhode on Photoshop
    12. Tomb of the Unpublished Scholar "advertisement" - Miron Murcury
    13. The Incredible Lent! -  José Alaniz
    13. Letters - Ian Gordon
    14. Whose Lent Is It Anway: Comics, Poetry, and Close-Reading - Bart Beaty
    14. J. Lent - Matt Wuerker
    15. Controlling Climate Change on Earth: Visionary Ideas from the Suske en Wiske Story The Cloud Eaters - Gert Meesters
    16. Peer Review -  Mike Rhode, modifying  James Montgomery Flagg*
    16. John Lent, Jedi - Thony Loui
    16. Mars Needs Political Cartoonists - Julian Lawrence
    17. Subject: Chrononautical Embedding: Temporal Paradox in Comic Art Historiography. Exhibit 1 - Charles Hatfield
    18. "Even a Large Language Model Can Cry": New Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence... - Marc Singer
    18. FTL Travel and the PPS Scholar -Gene Kannenberg, Jr.
    19. Baumgarten's Gnomes Join Batman at Summit of Scarcity... - Arthur van Kruining
    21. His powers are like the POWER OF TEN - Leonard Rifas



    Friday, February 20, 2026

    Graphic Novel Review: I Won’t Pretend These Missiles Are Stars. Life in Iran During the 12-Day War. An Anthology from The Cartoonist Collective in Tehran

     reviewed by John A. Lent, Founding Publisher/Editor-in Chief, International Journal of Comic Art

    The Cartoonist Collective. I Won’t Pretend These Missiles Are Stars. Life in Iran During the 12-Day War. An Anthology from The Cartoonist Collective in Tehran. Brooklyn, NY:  Street Noise Books, 2026. 212 pp. US $22.99 (Paperback). ISBN:  978-1951-491-55-0. https://www.streetnoisebooks.com/

     

     

    In these dark days, nothing is more important than spreading the voices of Iranians out there. In the end, we have only one request, remember us, remember Iran, and speak loudly about it.--The Cartoonist Collective

     

    It is February 19, and I write this, remembering Iran and my friends there, as war-monger and war-profiteer Trump has just deployed an overkill and provocative mission of multiple destroyers, the U.S.’s largest supercarrier, attack aircraft, drones, electronic warfare jets, and more to Iran in preparation for an invasion.

    I Won’t Pretend These Missiles Are Stars is an apt graphic novel to be reading at this time, with its vivid accounts of the fear, hopelessness, indecision, and sense of foreboding experienced by civilians when their abodes are under attack--in this case, those of Iranians during the 12 days in June 2025 when they suffered constant bombing by Israeli aircraft.

    Packaged in 15 segments, each told and illustrated by a member of Tehran’s The Cartoonist Collective, their titles foretold their contents, examples being, “I’ll Tell You a Story If We Don’t Die,” “Under the Same Roof,” “Until after the War,” “Stay Alive,” “Tehran Apocalypse,” and “The Fireworks.”

    The stories recount the wide array of feelings and preparatory plans and actions of those under threat of death. A sampling includes what, in normal times, would be considered preposterous or laughable:  “When bombs hit, my first instinct is not to scream but to prep my own corpse like a mortician on overtime.” “I still want to die but I have a deadline to meet.” “You can’t fully let your anger out, because you’re still raw from the last wound, and then it flares up again.” “It hurts my heart to see how people with dreams and hopes…become emotionless statistics when it serves the interests of the government.” “My friend stays up at night, hoping for peace and a clear sky, and I stay awake at night to think about my funeral.” “I hated the word war, that small three-lettered word, that took so much from us, the wounded people of Iran.” Another story shows a young female cartoonist decked out with loads of jewelry given to her by her mother and friends which she described as “a little something to hold on to as I passed away, or at least to make looting my corpse more of a luxury experience.”

    These stories are powerful accounts of non-military people encountering wartime conditions, which we seldom hear. The book is an assemblage of first-hand stories told in everyday conversation, drawn in a variety of styles and color schemes, and designed in an easy-to-follow format.

    I Won’t Pretend These Missiles Are Stars is highly-recommended for comics art practitioners, academicians, and aficionados, because of its superb storytelling and art, for anyone who still believes war is glamorous, and for the many of us who have not had to suffer war.

    Wednesday, February 11, 2026

    Book Review - The Early Reception of Manga in the West

     reviewed by C.T. Lim


    Martin de la Iglesia. The Early Reception of Manga in the West. Ch. A. Bachmann Verlag, 2023. ISBN 978-3-96234-077-3. <http://www.christian-bachmann.de/b_bn13.html>

    Comic studies’ publications in general are in bloom. One can imagine manga and anime scholarship studies in English (as distinct from scholarship written in Japanese) would constitute a big part of that given the popularity of manga and anime. Recent titles by Eike Exner and The Cambridge Companion to Manga and Anime edited by Jaqueline Berndt are notable. The Early Reception of Manga in the West is a fine addition to the list.

    de la Iglesia posits the origins of the popularity of manga in the West dating to when the first translated manga was published by independent publishers in America in the 1980s. He argues against the general perception that the manga boom started in the late 1990s, when dubbed anime adaptations of manga such as Dragon Ball or Sailor Moon were shown on television. 

    de la Iglesia focused on four titles as the starting point of manga’s acceptance in the West: Lone Wolf and Cub, Japan Inc, Akira, Crying Freeman. These were titles translated and published in America and Germany in the 1980s and 1990s, which Iglesia dubbed as the first manga wave of 1987 to 1995 (in the book’s back matter). 

    He argues though that the impact of the early translated manga in the 1980s and 1990s was limited. Although one can say that the publication of the 1970’s Lone Wolf and Cub by First Comics was a big deal in the American direct sales market, as it featured covers and introductions by famed cartoonists including Frank Miller, a hot property in the 1980s. Miller was visibly influenced by Japanese gegika manga such as Lone Wolf and Cub in his 1980s comics Daredevil, the four-issue Wolverine mini-series and Ronin. 

    Lone Wolf and Cub was soon followed by The Legend of Kamui, Mai the Psychic Girl and Area 88. American readers would also have been exposed to translated manga in Frederik Schodt’s landmark book, Manga! Manga! The World of Japanese Comics (1983) and I Saw It!, a comic book version of Barefoot Gen published by Leonard Rifas in 1982. And this is where, when reading this book, I am reminded how our mind plays tricks on us. We remember things differently. Some things we remember as bigger than they actually were. In my mind, the publication of the English version of Lone Wolf and Cub was a major comic book event. In reality, Iglesia proves empirically that Lone Wolf and Cub was not that significant in the whole scheme of things for manga publication in the West. In short, looking at the reception and sales of Lone Wolf and Cub, and Japan Inc in America and Germany, they are not significant to manga’s breakthrough in the West. But the Marvel Comics’ imprint Epic’s edition of Akira was the game changer, despite its more expensive prestige format. (p. 144) The Western comic book format was a hinderance to the success of Lone Wolf and Cub and the graphic novel format did not make Japan Inc a best seller, but Akira broke through the market.

    In terms of argument, approach and structure, the author borrows heavily from reception history, which is the fundamental art historical method used in this study. Its overall aim is to find out what people in certain regions of the world thought about manga at a certain time. (p. 10) Iglesia chose to focus on people rather than manga readers to get a broader sense of the reading audience. To quote: 

     

    Note that I deliberately use the generic term people instead of more specific ones such as manga fans or even manga readers. This is because the latter terms imply a particular subset of recipients who repeatedly or even regularly read manga and who already have a pre-formed opinion about manga that sets a positive expectation for their next act of reception; in other words, the act of manga reception has become a habit for them. In this study, the only prerequisite to qualify as a relevant recipient is that he or she has read at least one manga, or even only part of a manga. 

    But there is a problem with this approach. To quote:

     

    However, only a small fraction of these recipients have recorded their thoughts about their reception experience, and even less have done so in a form accessible to researchers today. The best bet for the researcher is to seek out records that have been both written down and published. The most common form of such records is a text in a magazine – most likely a specialised comic magazine (that is, a periodical that reports about comics, not an anthology of comics)… As a result, the group of recipients that I concentrate on is narrowed down to what I am going to refer to as journalists, be they professionals or amateurs, with vocational training in journalism or not. (p 10-11)

    Iglesia is aware of the limitations of taking journalists’ writings on manga at face value. 

     

    It is safe to say that the intent of a journalist writing about a comic is not, for instance, to give an accurate and objective picture of the manga reception of his or her time, and the intended recipient of his or her message is not a researcher working 30 years in the future. It is crucial to be aware of the original configuration of these acts of communication – of the intended recipient and the original intent of the journalist. We need to find out what the journalist wanted to achieve, as this intent shapes the content of his or her message, in order to extract the information we are interested in.

     

    Some journalists were even comic publishers themselves at the same time. A different but no less problematic incentive for journalists to review comics was the opportunity to obtain review copies – particularly as there was usually no (or only little) monetary compensation – which tempts journalists to write unduly positive reviews in the hope of receiving more review copies from the same publisher in the future. 

    Furthermore, 

     

    The importance of the role of journalists cannot be overstated, as they were a major part of, in the words of Bourdieu, the whole set of agents whose combined efforts produce consumers capable of knowing and recognizing the work of art as such. This means that the production of »the meaning and value of the work, that is, the attitude of readers towards individual manga titles, is to a certain extent shaped by critics (as well as publishers, who Bourdieu mentions explicitly). So in addition to trying to find out what a critic him- or herself thought about a particular manga, we should also aim to estimate the influence of a journalistic text on the attitude of the reader of that text towards the manga in question. (p. 11)

     

    Although in a footnote to this paragraph, Iglesia said that comic magazines are not widely read so their influence on readers would be limited. Again, this is a reminder not to take things at face value, but with a critical eye. The important point is this: the whole idea of perceiving manga as a genre has been brought about by these journalists. (p. 12)

    So to unpack the above, this book is really about the reception of manga by journalists and, in turn how the views of these journalists influence others' views and reception. But I would say this is problematic because how do you prove this? It is an issue of causation that cannot be solved easily. You can show a co-relation, but you cannot prove causation. On page 214, it was suggested that “by mapping one reception environment (Japan) onto the other (USA), one could speculate about the chances that such a hypothetical early manga translation would have had.” I doubt that is so. The book also does not examine the influence of manga on the American comics creators such as Miller because Iglesia argues “this kind of reception is hardly relevant to the larger question about the propagation of manga among the general public”, (p. 13), I disagree as Frank Miller was so popular at one point that his fans would read manga because of him. I know I did. 

    Chapter-wise, Iglesia examines his case studies by looking at their publication and reception in America, then in Germany. Deep analysis and comparison is being done here by looking at issue six (1987) of Lone Wolf and Cub as it was also the only one to be included in the first German edition of the series. For the Akira chapters, he looks at issues like flipping the art, coloring, script, charts to show the rank sales of Akira in Advance Comics Top 100, the number of cyberpunk scenes in the Akira issues and which year they appeared in. Akira is central to Iglesia’s argument; that is, if you accept his argument. 

    There are some things I disagree with. While he has proved with sales figures and reviews that Lone Wolf and Cub was a “modest cult hit” (p. 63), I disagree with the assessment that its “relative lack of success was most likely due to (the) rather mediocre quality of the original material (compared to Katsuhiro Ōtomo’s Akira, for example)” (p. 63). This same subjective assessment was also leveled on Crying Freeman, which was described as a “mediocre series” in the back matter. While Akira is great and I would say superior to many other manga series, too much acclaim is given to it. One need not dismiss Lone Wolf and Cub and Crying Freeman to argue Akira was good or important. His position does not accord with the fact that Freeman’s author Ryôichi Ikegami was given a highly acclaimed lifetime achievement award and a retrospective at the Angouleme Comics Festival a few years ago. 

    I am also not convinced by the utility of Chapter 8, Online Survey. It had 22 responses and it was a checklist to find out which manga were read when, in order to pinpoint the breakthrough of manga in the West. (p. 201) There were no open-ended questions. While Igelsia explained why he chose to conduct a survey instead of conducting in-depth interviews to get more responses, I believe interviews with 20 respondents would be richer and the resulting data more meaningful.

    Compared to the other case studies, the book devotes three chapters to Akira, both the manga, the anime and its connection to cyberpunk. He rightly pointed out the importance of cyberpunk in making the film popular, although the English edition of the manga was popular for other non-cyberpunk reasons. (p. 162) On this aspect of transmedia and intertextual context (p. 160), another area Iglesia could have explored is to compare the success of Akira as a film shown in the cinemas and Dragon Ball and Sailor Moon as anime shown on television, and how both events differ as turning points in making manga popular in the West. The difference in medium should tell another story. While outside the remit of this book, the impact of Ghost in the Shell film (1995) and the Neon Genesis Evangelion TV series would be interesting case studies. Other points he discussed are the importance of the adoption of the tankobon (roughly paperback) size in the eventual success of manga in the West (p. 199), and the issue of flipping artwork for publishing Sailor Moon and Dragon Ball. (p. 218)

    All in all, I enjoyed reading this book, as it brought me back to the 1980s of reading manga in English. Being in Singapore, I have been reading manga in Chinese. Recently I wrote a chapter on the reception of manga and anime in Singapore. This book exposed me to other reception approaches and theories. 

    Tuesday, February 3, 2026

    The Lent Comic Art Classification System, 2nd ed. available online now for free

    Long before the Library of Congress started revamping its cataloguing for comic art, John Lent had devised a system of his own. For his 90th birth year, we've updated the 2016 version and published it online for free with over 900 new terms added at https://archive.org/details/lent-comic-art-classificiation-2nd-ed-final/


    This classification system is derived from John A, Lent's 10-volume set of Comic Art Bibliography with additions and emendations by Mike Rhode from published versions of the Comics Research Bibliography.

    "In 1986, in preparation for a conference presentation in India, I self-published a 156-page international bibliography on comic art, which I also sent to some libraries and researchers. That led to the compilation of ten volumes of comic art sources, broken down by regions, genres, functions, and other aspects, published by Greenwood Press between 1994 and 2006. As I assembled materials for these bibliographies, I developed categories into which to place sources. The classification system presented in this monograph is the result. The classification system portrayed in these pages is meant to bring some order to filing, categorizing, and discussing comics and cartoons. Actually, the fullest section, on the United States, can be used with minor modifications to organize comic art studies about any country." - John Lent

    We're pleased to welcome Lizzy Walker to the team with this new edition, and expect to have annual updates. 

    A print-on-demand version for libraries is underway.

    Mike Rhode

    Wednesday, January 28, 2026

    Book Review - The Color of Paper: Representing Race in the Comics Medium by Chris Gavaler

     reviewed by Hélène Tison

    Chris Gavaler. The Color of Paper: Representing Race in the Comics Medium. Ohio State University Press, 2026. https://ohiostatepress.org/books/titles/9780814216040.html

    Chris Gavaler, a renowned comics scholar who has previously authored and co-authored several authoritative volumes of comics scholarship (such as The Comics Form: The Art of Sequenced Images in 2022; Creating Comics: A Writer’s and Illustrator’s Guide and Anthology in 2021; Superhero Comics in 2017) takes on the complex and fraught question of visual representations of race in graphic narratives: not only what formal elements are used to represent race, but how, combined with culturally constructed racial categories, they are interpreted by viewers.

    The Color of Paper is technically detailed and precisely referenced; Gavaler offers a clear methodology, provides a very pedagogical presentation of elaborate concepts in order to determine “how a material image composed of ink on paper conveys the culturally constructed concept of a racial category,” (1) and how the white page relates to racial Whiteness. He explains in the Introduction: “I attend to the physical (or discursive) qualities of an image that produce representational (or diegetic) qualities as perceived by individual viewers, because how those formal processes contribute to larger racial constructions is not fully understood.” (5)

    Gavaler combines his own very thorough formal analyses of a large number of comics, in color, grayscale or black and white, with data gathered through surveys in which viewers were asked to identify the race and ethnicity of comics characters. Gavaler acknowledges that the survey methodology is imperfect and considers the findings tentative; yet despite their shortcomings, they not only enable him (and his readers) to avoid generalizing from his (our) own perception, but they also do provide valuable input – and some unexpected results, at least for this reader: as an example, only 67% of initial respondents identified a childhood self-portrait of Ebony Flowers in Hot Comb as Black.

    The volume, alternating theoretical demonstrations and the application of theory to concrete examples, is clearly structured in four parts. “Backgrounds” analyzes page whiteness, exploring the division between surface and mark, the structuring effects of the white page’s “negative spaces,” such as gutters, and the unmarked areas whose default color represents skin color. Part 2, “Languages,” looks at what it means to “read” an image – generally through a combination of symbolic reading and non-symbolic observation – and, keeping in mind that race is not reducible to appearance, what it means to read race in an image.

    Based on this distinction and noting that there is currently no consensus concerning color analysis, the first chapter in Part 3 argues that non-realistic traditional coloring (CMYK) tends to encourage more symbolic reading than digital coloring, which appears more realistic. Gavaler then looks at black and white reprints of color comics, and at colored versions of initially black and white or grayscale comics, and at their reading by paired survey groups, to further determine the extent to which color contributes to denoting race.

    Part 4, “Bodies,” opens up the discussion to include gender, and turns to the relation between visual representations of (fictional or non-fictional) characters in figurative art (including comics) and the world beyond, the world of the viewer; it proposes “a theory of visual representation based on viewer perceptions of authorial intent, while also revealing an inherent gap between perceptions of race and gender and the actual racial and gender identities of represented individuals.” (211) Finally, Gavaler discusses the ways in which the physical space of reading, the spatial, overlayed relations of viewer/ comics, and the positionalities of viewers and creators, complicate the White gaze and the assumptions of Whiteness that have been dominant throughout the historical span of the medium. 

    Gavaler, who begins with a lucid discussion of what he describes as “the ambiguities of race as understood in the US,” or the “illogic of US racial thinking,” (8) does a sound, thorough and essential job, enabling his readers to make sense of our own readings of characters, putting clear and convincing words on perceptions that can otherwise remain imprecise. Inspired by such essential authors as Rebecca Wanzo and Qiana Whitted, and grounded in his impressive command of comics theory, he opts for a material, micro-level focus that is not only fruitful theoretically, but fascinating when, throughout the volume, he applies it to detailed analyses of a large number of extremely varied artists, from Herriman, Schulz, Sherald and Magritte to Eisner, Kirby, Miller, Heck, Grell, Hernandez, Abel, Bechdel, Passmore, Tomine, and Flowers, among many others.

    This is an essential read for anyone interested in understanding the ways in which race is represented and perceived in comics, as well as for anyone keen on comics theory.


    Tuesday, January 27, 2026

    Comics Research Bibliography 2025 and Addenda available online for free

    If you're reading this notice, there's a good chance you're in the new 1800 page annual update of the Bibliography, on its 30th anniversary. We're also commemorating John A. Lent's 90th birth year, since John started the field with his 10 volume set. Tony Rose has been assisting for the past couple of years, and librarian Elizabeth Walker has just joined the team. 

    The CRB is a worldwide bibliography of all types of comic art, including comic books, comic strips, caricature, gag cartoons, animation, editorial cartoons, biography, webcomics, political cartoons, history of cartooning, and comics scholarship.

    Our 30th Anniversary Edition has been updated with 3,327 new entries. It's downloadable at https://archive.org/details/crb-2025-ebook and there will be print edition in the coming month.

    An addenda of 2000 more pages of unsorted citations is at https://archive.org/details/crb-2025-addendum These citations have been formatted but not yet placed into the CRB. Many of them are from the first online iteration of the CRB, now preserved on the Internet Archive. For our 30th Anniversary and in honor of John Lent's 90th birth year, we are providing these as a resource the first time, since they are searchable by keyword. However, the goal remains to empty this document by placing all the citations into the main bibliography which is online now at Comics Research Bibliography. 
     

    While I have your attention, please consider subscribing to the International Journal of Comic Art at http://www.ijoca.net/ . And forward this to anyone you think might be interested.